My Lip Gloss:
1. What is the song basically saying about how to live a good life? Paraphrase the main idea.
The "good life" that the protagonist pursues in the "My Lip Gloss" video is to be cool. Being cool is associated with a number of specific items - using expensive products, getting a lot of sexual attention from the other sex, being resented by people of the same sex, the authorities praising you and wanting to imitate you. The video also shows a couple other themes - being famous (on the computers), using your powers to invigorate your chosen followers with amazing powers, running for class president, sparking a unified dance scene from the masses, commanding everyone's attention.
2. What lyrics particularly speak to that perspective? Use quotes as evidence.
"I just want to be a part of the cool crowd." That's Lil Mama's sole spoken ambition to set up the video and it is shared by everyone we see in the video. The skinny boy wearing blue is being pushed around by the mean kids in the hall but Lil Mama blows her magic lip gloss breath at him and he flips the script and drops his glasses and starts dancing the dance. He is now cool. Towards the end of the song ("8th period") the dean calls her to the office and asks Lil Mama to write down "where you get yours [lip gloss] from." Even the dean wants to be cool - dramatized in the video by letting her hair go free.
3. How do the video images support, re-orient, or challenge the dominant theme of the lyrics? Analyze.
The video extends the song in several ways. Each "becoming cool" moment is symbolized by a physical transformation - dropping the glasses, freeing the hair, dunking, being on the computers. But it is still all about being cool - being extraordinary - being the center of attention. Nothing particularly good or important is done (no ending of poverty or recognition of human solidarity or struggle against oppression) - other than a kind of carnival-like interruption of the normal school day. But hey - carnivalesque interruption of the school day (with those in power approving us but in their offices) is actually, as Lil Mama states later, "like wow".
4. What else do you notice that's interesting? Look for internal contradictions, aspects of the message that resonate with other messages from the pop culture, points that connect to your own perspective, etc. Analyze squared.
The dumb little ending "It wasn't the lip gloss it was you all along." Like Dumbo's feather and 10 other little revelation tropes (the ending scene in the film version of "the Natural") we are taught that the fetish we identify with isn't the real source of our power. This is the opposite of, for instance, the story of Samson.
In the context of "becoming cool" the message here is that the expensive product allows you to access the real power inside of you - the product is just a necessary "prop" but you are really the star. But that still leaves a big role for the expensive product - Lil Mama can "upgrade you" - but remember that L'Oreal isn't the real deal, its you that matters.
This is not interesting. This is the main line of advertising which both flatters our specialness and attacks our insecurity - the main message of advertising is that "our product can help you access your innate wonderfulness". So "My Lip Gloss" is simply a commercial hip hop fantasy that replicates corporate make-up commercials. The lack of any critical "edge" is made even more clear by the fact that in "My Lip Gloss" the mother is sympathetic and wise and the Dean is full of praise and wants to imitate the protagonist. So even the authority figures are conspiring to support the extraordinariness of the teen. This extraordinariness, then, can't be a rebellion against the established authority figures, but it can be a party in the lunch room. Which probably won't pose much danger to capitalism.
One other quick interesting point was that the video showed the protagnist and all her teen friends faces on the (macintosh) computer screens. That's today - facebook, myspace, etc. But then they say, "No music" and the scene abruptly breaks to the "real" images of the teen and her circle and she's spitting rhymes to just hand claps. This distinction between the "virtual" and "real" in a video which is actually itself faked and virtual, is kind of weird. The distinction "fake" and "real" is of course what the "Lip Gloss" thing is about - and maybe the confusion between the two is what "cool" is about.
Finally there is something weird going on with the emphases in "I be rubbing it" but I'll leave that to others to analyze.
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Andy,
ReplyDeletei think that your analysis of the video was correct and elped change my mind of the meaning of the video. at first, i didn;t know exactly what the meaning was behind the video, btu after reading your analysis and evidence to back your analsis up, i realized that what you are syaing is correct. because Lil Mama has the lip gloss in her hand, she is cool and popular. nice analysis =)
-Rachel
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI didn't notice how in the video during all of the attention she was getting, she was also in control and how everyone followed her. I agree that most people feel like material goods will get them far. Even Lil Mama's mom goes on to say how it was her all along and not the lip gloss but Lil Mama doesn't listen cause she likes all the attention she's getting. Music videos are also another way to advertise things its not all about the music and words like with L'Oreal paying to put their product in the video, so when people watch it they would want the product.
ReplyDeleteThat was a great analysis of the video, and I guess it can be seen where it's a "longer" commercial. I guess in a sense, it's trying to tell lipgloss with a greater meaning.
ReplyDeleteAnd I can't say I enjoy that song at all. The video was a bit entertaining, and reading your analysis helped me catch a lot of the things that direct towards reinforcing the video's meaning
I would have to agree with your analysis because the youth today is so influenced with what they see, they don't realize that all the material stuff will go to waste one day or another. The style, teens have today always wear out and when something new comes out everyone is out to look that same way. While others are in fact trying to be different than those who want to be just like their favorite celebrity and so on.
ReplyDeleteI never really looked at the video the way you viewed it but i get an understanding now of what the meaning of the video and how the media brainwashes people to be someone they're not.
I think that your analysis of the video is dead-on. However I would try to analyze another possibility - Lil Mama says "what you know 'bout me" and so perhaps she is saying how we're all so caught up in being "cool" that we never know the person under the cool, all we know is that they're the cool kid for a reason.
ReplyDeleteI think the best thing you pointed out was "So even the authority figures are conspiring to support the extraordinariness of the teen. This extraordinariness, then, can't be a rebellion against the established authority figures, but it can be a dance party in the lunch room" I didnt put real thought into that part at first, but thinking about it now, doesn't it make your extraordinariness a hollow position? WIth no one to contest it, you havent really accomplished all that much.
G -
ReplyDeleteYes - that's what I'm trying to say - that the video offers a false vision of teen empowerment - one where the adults happily abdicate both responsibility and power and let the teens just do what they want - one where there is "progress" but "no struggle" (in Frederick Douglass's words).
It is hollow because people in power don't give up power without struggle - as you imply the people who are running the system like the system the way it is and aren't going to let someone just come by and change it because they look cute. and it is false because it pretends to offer youth power but it doesn't challenge any of the facets of daily life which disempower youth - neither the representatives of the system (teachers, deans, cops, parents, bosses) nor the functioning of the system (people sitting bored in classes, the corporate vampires, the eco-system destroyers, the armies.
there is no "against" in the video - just the cool crowd that lil mama is trying to join, just the dean who turns out to be an ally, just the masses that clap along for lil mama when she wants to spit her rhyme. the closest that the video comes to an opponent are the other girls in the hallway who are jealous and roll their eyes because lil mama is getting all the male attention.
so this video is a wish-fulfillment dream of a narcissistic young black urban high school student. and i think its a pretty accurate one. the goal of critique and theory is to reveal what that dream lacks - the hollowness that the dream portrays as victory.
You give a clear definition on what the video was demonstrating (the girl looking good, the items used, social class,etc). Your analysis on the song's message connects to what you have been lately communticating about popular culture. This assigment was a great example to your lesson, and it also helps practice our analysis on messages given by society.
ReplyDelete-Lieb